Philosophy of Social Sciences Ted Benton & Ian Craib

Overview

Philosophy of Social Sciences introduces key ideas and concepts while raising questions and opening debates. This book remains essential reading for all students of social theory and social science research.

Publisher Bloomsbury Academic
ISBN 9781350329089
Year 2023
Pages314
Format PDF

Summary

Philosophers and social scientists have long shared a common curiosity: understanding who we are and how the world we live in really works. But how do philosophy and the social sciences actually come together, and why does that connection matter? This fully revised third edition of a widely respected book explores these questions in a clear, accessible, and engaging way.

Updated with a new introduction and reflective commentaries, the book revisits its original chapters in light of recent debates and developments in the field. It also features two brand-new chapters on critical social science and on one of the most pressing challenges facing social scientists today: making sense of the complex relationship between human societies and the natural world, particularly in the context of biodiversity loss and climate change.

Philosophy of Social Sciences offers a clear and accessible introduction to the foundations of social science, with no prior background required. It tackles key questions about what social science is, how it works, and how it relates to the natural sciences, helping readers make sense of the field from the ground up.

Bringing together both classic and contemporary perspectives, the book guides readers through a wide range of approaches—from empiricism and positivism to rationalism and post-structuralism—while encouraging critical thinking and debate throughout. Written in a lively, student-friendly style, it introduces core ideas and concepts without oversimplifying them.

A cornerstone of the Traditions in Social Theory series, this book continues to be essential reading for students of social theory and social science research.

Contents

  • Introduction to the First Edition
    • Philosophy and the Social Sciences
    • A Philosophical Toolkit
    • Politics and Political Philosophy
    • The Book and Its Arguments
    • How to Read the Book
  • Empiricism and Positivism in Science
    • Empiricism and the Theory of Knowledge
    • Positivism and Sociology
  • Further Reading
  • Some Problems of Empiricism and Positivism
    • Two Ways to Criticize Positivism
    • Some Problems of Empiricism
    • Further Problems of Positivism
    • Further Reading
  • Science, Nature and Society: Some Alternatives to Empiricism
    • Marxism and Science
    • Weber, Merton and the Sociology of Science
    • Historical Epistemology and Structural Marxism
    • Revolutions and Relativism: From Kuhn to the Strong Programme
    • Gender and Science: The Feminist Vision
    • The Reflexive Turn: Constructing Nature and Society
    • Conclusion
    • Further Reading
    • Postscript
  • Interpretive Approaches I: Instrumental Rationality
    • Weber’s Discussion of the Objects of the Social Sciences
    • Weber’s Methodology: Understanding and Ideal Types
    • Weber on Objectivity and Value Freedom
    • Phenomenology as a Foundation for Instrumental Rationality
    • Rational Choice Theory
    • Pragmatism and Symbolic Interactionism
    • Individualism, Holism and Functional Explanation
    • Reasons and Causes
    • Conclusion
    • Further Reading
    • Postscript
  • Interpretive Approaches II: Rationality as Rule-Following
    • Peter Winch: Philosophy and Social Science
    • Language, Games and Rules
    • Understanding Other Societies
    • What Can We Do with Winch?
    • Alasdair MacIntyre: Narratives and Communities
    • Hermeneutics: Hans-Georg Gadamer
    • Conclusion
    • Further Reading
    • Postscript
  • Interpretive Approaches III: Critical Rationality
    • Hegel, Marx and the Dialectic
    • The Dialectic of the Enlightenment
    • Ideology
    • Habermas and Emancipatory Science
    • Critical Theory and the Linguistic Turn
    • Conclusion
    • Further Reading
    • Postscript
  • Critical Realism and the Social Sciences
    • Realism and Natural Science
    • Experiments, Laws and Mechanisms
    • Reality as Stratified
    • Emergence and Reduction
    • Closed and Open Systems
    • Realism and Social Science
    • Human Emancipation
    • Further Reading
    • Postscript
  • Feminism, Knowledge and Society
    • Objectivity and Cultural Diversity
    • Feminist Politics and Social Knowledge
    • Feminism and Epistemology
    • The Feminist Standpoint Debate
    • Post-modern Feminism
    • Further Reading
    • Postscript
  • Post-structuralism and Post-modernism
    • The Move to the Signifier
    • Foucault and the Construction of the Subject
    • Derrida and Deconstruction
    • Losing Philosophy
    • The Politics of the Posts
    • Further Reading
    • Postscript
  • Conclusion to the First Edition: In Defence of Philosophy
  • Commentary on Recent Developments
    • Peter Winch and Hermeneutics
    • Meaning, Action and Explanation
    • Understanding Other Cultures
    • Human Nature and Social Science Naturalism
    • Post-Marxism and Post-Structuralism
    • Critical Realism and Social Science
    • Morphogenesis and Human Flourishing
    • Recent Interventions
  • Critical Social Science, Nature and Human Nature
    • Philosophical Anthropology
    • Humans as Social and Natural Beings
    • Ecological and Social Embeddedness
    • Disrupted Metabolism with Nature
  • Nature, Economy and Society
    • Sustainable Development
    • Environmental Economics
    • Alternatives
    • Classical Political Economy
    • Marx, Engels and Ecology
    • Ecological Marxism and the Metabolic Rift
  • Appendix: Personal Conclusions (1st Edition, 2001)
  • Appendix: Obituary for Professor Ian Craib (1945-2002)

Extract

Philosophy and the Social Sciences

Philosophy and the social sciences are usually seen as separate subjects, so why should students of the social sciences be interested in philosophy? We hope that this question will answer itself by the end of this book, but we can begin to address it right away.

When modern science was emerging in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, it was difficult to determine where the boundary between philosophy and science should be drawn. It was only later that a clearer separation between the two became conventional. As this separation took place, two basic models of their relationship emerged.

According to the first model, philosophy could arrive at certain knowledge through rational argument. The most fundamental truths about ourselves and about the nature of the world, as well as the rules for acquiring such knowledge, could be established by philosophers. In this way, philosophy provided the foundations for research in particular scientific disciplines. This view is sometimes called the masterbuilder or master-scientist conception of philosophy, and it is closely associated with metaphysics.

In metaphysics, philosophers attempt to give an account of the universe, the world, and everything in it. Today, however, philosophers tend to be more modest in their ambitions.

The alternative model of the relationship between philosophy and the sciences is often referred to as the underlabourer view. According to this perspective, armchair speculation about the nature of the world cannot provide certain or reliable knowledge. Instead, knowledge can only come from practical experience, observation, and systematic experimentation.

From this standpoint, the special sciences do not need philosophers to provide foundations or to dictate how they should think. Rather, philosophy should assist and support scientists as they carry out the work of discovering how nature operates. But what kind of help can philosophy offer?

One influential answer is that common-sense thinking often contains prejudices, superstitions, and unquestioned assumptions that hinder scientific progress. Philosophy can help by identifying and criticizing these obstacles, thereby clearing the way for science to advance. This role is sometimes compared to clearing dead leaves from a railway track so that the trains can run freely.

Book Details

Title Philosophy of Social Sciences
Subtitle The Philosophical Foundations of Social Thought
Autor Ted Benton & Ian Craib
Publisher Bloomsbury Academic
Year 2023
Pages314
CountryGreat Britain
ISBN 9781350329089
Format PDF
Filesize 4.6 MB
URL Ted Benton & Ian Craib Philosophy of Social Sciences PDF