The Structure of Social Action (1937) by Talcott Parsons analyzes how Marshall, Pareto, Durkheim, and Weber converged toward a voluntaristic theory of action. It bridges positivism and idealism, emphasizing human agency, subjective meanings, and shared norms in shaping social order and stability.
Publisher
The Free Press
ISBN
9780029242605
Year
1949
Pages
817
Summary
Nearly twelve years have passed since the original publication of The Structure of Social Action by Talcott Parsons. The post-war wave of interest in theoretical study and teaching in the relevant aspects of social science unfortunately found the book out of print, so that the decision of The Free Press to bring out a new edition is most welcome.
For a variety of reasons, it has been decided to reprint the original book without change. There is, in this decision, no implication that the book could not be substantially improved by revision. Nothing could be further both from the spirit of the work and from a number of explicit statements in it. The author’s own process of theoretical thinking has not stopped, and if he were to undertake writing the book again at this time, it would come out a substantially different and, let us hope, a better book.
To present a revised version which would at all closely resemble what the book would be like if newly written in 1949 would, however, be a very heavy task. It would not only involve much actual rewriting, but, prior to that, a careful re-study and re-evaluation of the principal sources on which it was based. This would certainly be highly productive, but the problem is to balance judgment of the productiveness of such work compared to alternative uses of the time and energy it would require.
The most important consideration involved in the balance is the relative advantage to be derived from further refinement of the critical analysis of theoretical work done a generation and more ago as compared with the probable fruitfulness of proceeding with direct analysis of theoretical problems in relation to presently going empirical research interests without further refinement of critical orientation. The decision not to embark on a thorough revision of the book represents the judgment that in the present situation of social science, the latter constitutes the more fruitful channel for a major investment of time and energy.
The Structure of Social Action was intended to be primarily a contribution to systematic social science and not to history, that is the history of social thought.
Contents
PART I: THE POSITIVISTIC THEORY OF ACTION
Chapter I. Introductory
The Problem 3
Theory and Empirical Fact 6
Residual Categories 16
Theory, Methodology and Philosophy 20
Types of Concepts 27
Note on the Concept “Fact” 41
Chapter II. The Theory of Action
The Unit of Action Systems 43
The Utilitarian System 51
The Positivistic Theory of Action 60
Empiricism 67
Individualism in the Theory of Action 72
Note A: On the Concept “Normative” 74
Note B: Schematic Outline of System Types in the Theory of Action 77
Note C: On the Content of Nonsubjective Categories in Relation to the Theory of Action 82
Note D: On the Relations of Psychology and Biology 85
Chapter III. Some Phases of the Historical Development of Individualistic Positivism in the Theory of Action
Hobbes and the Problem of Order 89
Locke and the Classical Economics 95
Malthus and the Instability of Utilitarianism 102
Marx and Class Antagonism 107
Darwinism 110
Other Paths to Radical Positivism 115
Utility 121
Evolution 122
PART II: THE EMERGENCE OF A VOLUNTARISTIC THEORY OF ACTION FROM THE POSITIVISTIC TRADITION
Chapter IV. Alfred Marshall: Wants and Activities and the Problem of the Scope of Economics
Activities and Utility Theory 130
The Supplies of the Factors of Production 141
Real Cost 146
Free Enterprise 150
Social Evolution 155
The “Natural Order” 159
Economic Motives 161
The Problem of the Scope of Economic Theory 165
Chapter V. Vilfredo Pareto, I: The Methodology and Main Analytical Scheme
Methodology 180
Logical and Nonlogical Action 185
Residues and Derivations 196
The Two Structural Aspects of Nonlogical Action 200
Chapter VI. Vilfredo Pareto, II: Extension and Verification of the Structural Analysis
Pareto and Social Darwinism 219
The “Logical” Aspect of Action Systems 228
The Theory of Social Utility 241
The Nonlogical Aspect of Social Systems 250
The Status of Economic Theory Again 264
Chapter VII. Vilfredo Pareto, III: Empirical Generalizations and Conclusions
The Ideology Problem 269
Cycles of Social Change 278
The Role of Force 288
General Conclusions 293
Chapter VIII. Émile Durkheim, I: Early Empirical Work
The Division of Labor 308
Suicide 324
Occupational Groups and Socialism 338
Chapter IX. Émile Durkheim, II: The Methodology of Sociologistic Positivism
The Utilitarian Dilemma 344
The “Social” Factor 350
Collective Representations 359
Ethics and the Social Type 368
Chapter X. Émile Durkheim, III: The Development of the Theory of Social Control
The Changing Meaning of Constraint 378
Ethical Difficulties 390
The Role of Institutions 399
Chapter XI. Émile Durkheim, IV: The Final Phase, Religion and Epistemology
Religious Ideas 411
Ritual 429
Epistemology 441
Chapter XII. Summary of Part II: The Breakdown of the Positivistic Theory of Action
The Positivistic Starting Points 451
Marshall 452
Pareto 454
Durkheim 460
PART III: THE EMERGENCE OF A VOLUNTARISTIC THEORY OF ACTION FROM THE IDEALISTIC TRADITION
Chapter XIII. The Idealistic Tradition
Methodological Background 473
The Problem of Capitalism 487
Marx 488
Sombart 495
Chapter XIV. Max Weber, I: Religion and Modern Capitalism (A. Protestantism and Capitalism)
The Principal Characteristics of Capitalism 503
The Spirit of Capitalism 513
Calvinism and the Spirit of Capitalism 516
Note on the Role of Ideas 533
Chapter XV. Max Weber, II: Religion and Modern Capitalism (Continued) (B. The Comparative Studies)
China 542
India 552
The Systematic Typology of Religion 563
Protestantism and Capitalism Schematic Summary 575
Chapter XVI. Max Weber, III: Methodology
Objectivism 581
Intuitionism 586
Natural and Social Science 591
The Ideal Type and Generalized Analytical Theory 601
The Logic of Empirical Proof 610
Adequacy of Explanation 624
Action and Complexes of Meaning 635
Chapter XVII. Max Weber, IV: Systematic Theory
The Types of Social Action 640
Modes of Orientation of Action 649
Legitimate Order, Charisma and Religion 658
Ritual 673
Matters of Taste 677
Note on Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft 686
PART IV: CONCLUSION
Chapter XVIII. Empirically Verified Conclusions
Summary Outline of the Structure of Action 698
Rationality and Utilitarianism 698
Marshall 702
Pareto 704
Durkheim 708
Weber 714
Verified Conclusions 719
Chapter XIX. Tentative Methodological Implications
Empiricism and Analytical Theory 728
The Action Frame of Reference 731
Systems of Action and Their Units 737
The Role of Analytical Elements 748
The General Status of the Theory of Action 753
The Classification of the Sciences of Action 757
The Place of Sociology 768
Extract
The Structure of Social Action analyzed a process of convergent theoretical development which constituted a major revolution in the scientific analysis of social phenomena. The three principal authors treated in that study are by no means isolated, but as contributors to the “sociological” side of the development, the added perspective of another decade does not diminish their relative stature as high points in the movement. There is an elevated range, not just three peaks, but these three peaks loom far higher than the lesser ones.
This is true on the sociological side. A major one-sidedness of the book is its relative neglect of the psychological aspects of the total conceptual scheme—a balance which a thorough revision would certainly have to attempt to redress. Here, at least, one figure in the same generation as the others, that of Freud, looms up as having played a cardinal role in a development which, in spite of the differences of his starting points and empirical concerns, must be regarded as a vital part of the same general movement of thought.
Psychology is probably richer in significant secondary figures than is true on the sociological side, but no other one seems closely to approach the stature of Freud. So much is this the case that a full-dress analysis of Freud’s theoretical development seen in the context of the “theory of social action”—and adaptation of the rest of the book to the results of such an analysis—would seem indispensable to the kind of revision which ought to be undertaken. This would, of course, necessarily result in a substantial lengthening of an already formidable work.
Author
Talcott Parsons (1902–1979) was a prominent American sociologist best known for developing structural functionalism and action theory. His influential work, The Structure of Social Action (1937), synthesized ideas from Weber, Durkheim, and Pareto to create an integrated framework for analyzing social order. As a key figure at Harvard University, Parsons shaped 20th-century sociology by studying how cultural values, institutions, and individual actions sustain social stability.
Book Details
Title
The Structure of Social Action
Subtitle
A Study in Social Theory with Special Reference to a Group of Recent European Writers